Patient and tooth-related factors in the loss of molars in maintenance

Summarised from:

The loss of molars in supportive periodontal care: A 10-year follow-up for tooth- and patient-related factors.
(Journal of Clinical Periodontology; doi: 10.1111/jcpe.13585)

Authors:

Fernando Oliveira Costa, José Roberto Cortelli, Sheila Cavalca Cortelli, Amanda Almeida Costa, Rafael Paschoal Esteves Lima, Adriana Moreira Costa, Gustavo Henrique Mattos Pereira, Luís Otávio Miranda Cota

Summarised by:

Dr Varkha Rattu

Research Topic:

Background + Aims

  • Tooth loss (TL), a significant outcome of periodontitis, affects patients physiologically and psychologically. Periodontal therapy and patient compliance during supportive periodontal care (SPC) are crucial in reducing TL risk.
  • Studies highlight patient- and tooth-related factors influencing TL, including periodontal bone loss, tooth mobility, furcation involvement (FI), tooth type, and vitality, with FI identified as a major predictor of molar survival.
  • Molars with FI are particularly prone to further attachment loss and have double the risk of being lost during SPC.
  • This study aimed to evaluate the impact of FI on molar longevity and factors influencing molar loss during SPC.

Materials + Methods

  • The study analysed data from 222 patients diagnosed with stage II-IV periodontitis who underwent SPC for at least 10 years in a private dental clinic.
  • Clinical parameters, including probing depth, clinical attachment level, and furcation involvement (FI), were recorded at baseline (T1) and after 10 years (T2).
  • The study assessed molar loss (ML) as the primary outcome and identified contributing tooth- and patient-related factors, including FI degree, compliance, smoking, diabetes, and socio-economic factors.
  • Treatment included non-surgical and surgical interventions, such as resective surgery for FI II, root amputation, hemisection or tunnelling procedures for FI – III.
  • Tooth vitality was assessed using sensitivity tests and radiographic assessments.
  • Compliance was evaluated based on SPC attendance.
  • Statistical analyses, including multilevel Cox regression and mediation analysis, were used to identify, respectively, the independent risk factors and assess the role of compliance in the relationship between FI and molar survival.

Results

  • Loss of molar teeth was analysed amongst 222 patients with stage II-IV periodontitis undergoing 12.4 years of SPC.
  • Of 5,315 teeth present at baseline (T1), 542 teeth were lost by follow-up (T2), including 235 molars (43.2% of all teeth lost).
  • The molar survival rate during SPC was 82.3%, with loss of molars strongly associated with furcation involvement (FI). Molars with FI = III exhibited the highest relative risk (RR = 19.7) for loss compared to FI = 0.
  • Periodontal parameters, including probing depth and bleeding on probing, significantly worsened over time.
  • Compliance with SPC mitigated the risk of ML, with non-compliers exhibiting a hazard ratio (HR) of 2.42.
  • Patient-related factors significantly associated with ML included age >50 years (HR = 1.41), male gender (HR = 1.21), diabetes (HR = 3.12), and smoking (HR = 3.73).
  • Tooth-related factors such as FI = II (HR = 2.63), FI = III (HR = 5.23), probing depths ≥5 mm (HR = 3.78), and non-vitality (HR = 2.88) were strongly predictive of ML.
  • The mediation analysis demonstrated a significant role of compliance in mitigating molar loss risk associated with FI, with compliance explaining 89.5% of the mediation effect.

Limitations

  • The retrospective design may have resulted in potential selection, performance, and reporting biases.
  • Despite efforts to minimise inaccuracies through standardisation of data collection and procedures, furcation involvement (FI) diagnosis may still lack precision, as only the most severe FI per molar was assessed.
  • The single private practice setting, exclusion of third molars, and variability in supportive periodontal care intervals limit the generalisability of the findings to the population.
  • Tooth loss decisions may be influenced by non-clinical factors such as patient or dentist preferences.

Conclusion

  • Molars with FI class III and no pulp vitality have reduced survival.
  • Smoking, diabetes, and compliance are critical in treatment decisions for deciding whether to retain or extract molars in patients with periodontitis.
  • These findings underscore the importance of SPC compliance and targeted interventions for high-risk teeth.
Read the full article Back to Research

Research  |  14.12.21

clock icon 6 mins to read

Share this page:

Copy Link

You might also like...

Events

Oral Health Challenges Among People Living With Diabetes

Dr Antoniszczak will present a lecture about the oral health challenges among people living with diabetes. This lecture explores the key challenges faced by individuals living with diabetes, focusing on…

Read more

Events

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub x #DiabetesChat

Hosted by #diabeteschat, join Dr Varkha Rattu and the team behind the Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub for an insightful discussion exploring the importance of managing periodontitis and diabetes.

Read more

Events

Oral Health Challenges Among People Living With Diabetes

Dr Antoniszczak will present a lecture about the oral health challenges among people living with diabetes. This lecture explores the key challenges faced by individuals living with diabetes, focusing on the relationship between diabetes and oral health.

Read more

Events

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub x #DiabetesChat

Hosted by #diabeteschat, join Dr Varkha Rattu and the team behind the Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub for an insightful discussion exploring the importance of managing periodontitis and diabetes.

Read more
icon1 services

Periodontitis is the 6th most prevalent condition globally

icon1 services

Periodontitis and diabetes are bidirectionally linked

icon1 services

Diabetic complications are increased if you have both diseases

icon1 services

Successful periodontal treatment can improve blood glucose control

icon1 services

Successful periodontal treatment can improve blood glucose control

icon1 services

Periodontitis is the 6th most prevalent condition globally

icon1 services

Periodontitis and diabetes are bidirectionally linked

icon1 services

Diabetic complications are increased if you have both diseases

icon1 services

Successful periodontal treatment can improve blood glucose control

icon1 services

Successful periodontal treatment can improve blood glucose control

Our Team

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Varkha Rattu

Founder & Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Amar Puttanna

Diabetes Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Rajeev Raghavan

Diabetes Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Professor Mark Ide

Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Professor Luigi Nibali

Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Dominika Antoniszczak

Education & Support Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Jasmine Loke

Clinical Content Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Mira Shah

Patient Resource Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Elaine Tilling

Outreach & Communications Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Varkha Rattu

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Founder & Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Amar Puttanna

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Diabetes Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Rajeev Raghavan

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Diabetes Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Professor Mark Ide

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Professor Luigi Nibali

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Periodontology Co-Lead

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Dominika Antoniszczak

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Education and Support Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Jasmine Loke

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Clinical Content Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Dr Mira Shah

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Patient Resource Advisor

Team - The Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub

Elaine Tilling

Periodontitis-Diabetes Hub Position: Outreach and Communications Lead

View All